About

The Paulson Insurance Advantage

When you choose Paulson Insurance, you not only get affordable Evansville auto insurance, you get the advantage of choosing coverage and price from 12 insurance companies! Choose the coverage that fits your needs and budget.

Auto Insurance




Home Insurance




Health Insurance




Life Insurance




Josh Paulson

Josh started Paulson Insurance in 2010 after working in the insurance industry a couple of years for a captive company. He saw the benefit of being an independent agent and the value it brings to our clients. He received his Bachelors Degree in Management from the University of Southern Indiana. He is also a member of the Downtown Optimist Club. Outside of work, Josh enjoys camping and spending time with his wife and three boys.

Katie Thornberry
Katie has been a part of the Paulson Insurance team since 2014. She specializes in home, auto, and life insurance. She received her Bachelors Degree in Finance from the University of Southern Indiana. Katie is passionate about educating our clients on their coverages and being a resource to them in a time of need. Outside of work, she loves inspiring others through healthy living and fitness. She and her husband reside on the northside of Evansville and are involved in various ministries at their church.
Meredith Woodard
After working in membership experience and management at Bob's Gym for 9 years, Meredith is quite pleased to shift gears and join the team at Paulson, bringing her skills of analysis, problem-solving, and of course customer service. Her degrees are in Theatre Arts and French and she still enjoys being active in the theatre community and polishing her French skills, whether through tutoring or confusing people by uttering French phrases unexpectedly. She also continues to pursue fitness goals, and serves in church and the community.
affordable Evansville auto insurance
Natalie Terry
Natalie has been with Paulson Insurance since 2018. With over 15 years of experience in customer service, she provides exemplary assistance to our clients. She enjoys spending time with her friends and family, including her four beautiful children. One of her favorite things to do is to cheer her kids on at their sporting events. She also enjoys going to church with them.
affordable Evansville auto insurance
Amanda Pendergraff
Born and raised in Evansville, Indiana, Amanda is the mother of two boys and has been with her husband since a teenager in high school. She has worked everything from call centers to factory work, until she realized that insurance was her real calling. Using her ability to relate with our clients gives her the opportunity to build relationships. When she isn't at work, she enjoys watching football, shopping with her mom, or binging a good Netflix series. She plans to travel with her husband and continue to be both of her boys' #1 fan!